The Pie That Was Northern Aggression
This post contains affiliate links, marked with an asterisk.
Here’s something I didn’t know until I read Ariel Knoebel’s piece for Atlas Obscura, For Decades, Southern States Considered Thanksgiving an Act of Northern Aggression. Really.
In the 1800s, Southern governors refused to proclaim the holiday, politicians called Thanksgiving propaganda, and whole states dragged their feet on the calendar out of spite. And the humble, orange, faintly smug little pumpkin pie sitting in the middle of it all was the flag everybody was mad about. So I fell down the rabbit hole, and I’m taking y’all with me, because the real story is stranger and better than the one on the placemat, and it’s changed how I feel about the whole month of November.
Start with the story we’ve all been handed since we were kids. You know how it goes: Pilgrims in buckle hats, a long friendly table, grateful Natives passing the corn, everybody getting along, roll credits. It’s the version that got construction-papered onto elementary school bulletin boards all over America.
Putting on my historian hat, I can tell you that almost none of it holds up. There was a harvest gathering at Plymouth in 1621, sure. But the tidy national origin story, the one with the built-in moral about strangers becoming friends, got assembled much later and for very specific reasons. Nobody sat those colonists and the Wampanoag down and said “behold, a tradition.”
And the people who were actually there have their own account of what followed, which was not a friendship. Since 1970, members of the Wampanoag and other nations have gathered at Plymouth every fourth Thursday of November for a National Day of Mourning, organized by the United American Indians of New England. It started when a Wampanoag man named Wamsutta Frank James was invited to speak at a big anniversary banquet and then disinvited once the organizers read what he planned to say. So he said it outside, on the hill: “This is a time of celebration for you – celebrating an anniversary of a beginning for the white man in America. A time of looking back, of reflection. It is with a heavy heart that I look back upon what happened to my People…”
So that’s the first thing. The friendly-pilgrims story is a costume. The colonization underneath it was real and it was brutal, and the mourning isn’t a buzzkill somebody invented to ruin your day. It’s still going on, every Thanksgiving, more than fifty years later.
Now for the other side of it.
Thanksgiving as a national holiday was, in large part, one woman’s decades-long lobbying campaign. Her name was Sarah Josepha Hale, and she was the editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book, one of the most widely read magazines in the country (think of the reach of a morning show, except it’s a monthly and it’s teaching the whole nation how to keep house). Back in 1827 she’d published a novel called Northwood with a loving chapter on a New England Thanksgiving, and right there on the table, described like the crown jewel of the whole affair, was the pumpkin pie. For years afterward she wrote editorials and letters to governors and presidents, politely and relentlessly, trying to make the day official.
A lot of the South wanted absolutely nothing to do with it.
By the 1850s, Thanksgiving read as a New England thing, and New England read as abolitionist. It came with Yankee preachers giving Yankee sermons, and those sermons had an increasingly obvious point of view about slavery. So Southern leaders treated it as exactly what it looked like: a holiday pushed on them by the people trying to end slavery. In 1856 the governor of Virginia, Henry Wise, wrote back to Hale that he wanted nothing to do with “this theatrical national claptrap of Thanksgiving,” which he blamed for setting pulpits to preaching “Christian politics.” That was his tidy way of saying abolition. Some Southern governors moved the date on purpose so it wouldn’t line up with the North’s. Texas had a former Confederate officer for a governor who was still refusing to proclaim the thing into the 1880s. (Of course it was Texas. I say that with love; I’m from there.)
They weren’t confused about the pie. Pumpkin pie was the edible mascot of the people trying to end slavery, and they didn’t want it on their tables.
Lincoln made the holiday national in the middle of the Civil War, on October 3, 1863, and he framed it less as the North winning an argument and more as a wounded country looking for something to be grateful for. (Congress didn’t nail the date down until 1941.)
So is pumpkin pie political? It was. It was on the right side of the biggest moral fight in this country’s history, and it caught real flak for it.
The South didn’t just refuse and pout. The South answered, and the answer is one of the best things on any holiday table in America: sweet potato pie.
This is the part I want to get right, because it’s exactly the kind of credit that usually goes missing. Sweet potato pie isn’t just “the Southern version.” It’s a Black American dish, built by enslaved and later free African American cooks who took the sweet potato, the closest thing in the South to the yams of West African cooking, and made something that outshines the pie it was standing in for. It’s a cornerstone of soul food, and a whole lot of Black families would look at you sideways for replacing it with pumpkin. If you want that history told in full, Michael Twitty’s The Cooking Gene* is the book. He traces how African and African American hands built the Southern table with more depth than any blog post of mine could manage.
So even the rival pie has a better story.
Which brings me to the guilt. A lot of us walk into November carrying a vague, low-grade guilt about Thanksgiving, and when you pull it apart, most of it is attached to the fairy tale: the hand-turkey pageant, the fake friendship, the sanitized story we now know isn’t real. Retire the fairy tale, absolutely. But you don’t have to do penance to a cartoon.
The real history isn’t the thing to feel guilty about. It’s a holiday that started as a stand for union, a pie that took heat for being on the right side, a rival pie that carries the genius of Black cooks who were never properly thanked, and a Native truth-telling that’s been going on at Plymouth since 1970 and asks only that you hear it. None of that requires you to skip dinner. It asks you to know what you’re eating and who you’re thanking, which, if you’ve been around this blog for five minutes, you know is my entire deal.
So here’s what I’d suggest. Ditch the pageant and keep the gratitude. Say the real history out loud at your table, even just a sentence of it. Credit the cooks. Make a sweet potato pie next to your pumpkin one. (Yes, I make eight pies every Thanksgiving and not one of them is sweet potato. I know.) And then eat, generously and happily, with your people.
Paying attention has never once made a pie taste worse.
And yes, there’s a pie that goes with all of this. My ginger-crust pumpkin pie recipe is coming after Thanksgiving, once I have real photos of the pie and this year’s prep to go with it.

Pumpkin or sweet potato at your table? (Both is a correct answer.) Let me know in the comments.

P.S. The most American thing I researched all month is a dessert that half the country once treated as enemy propaganda. We are a deeply unserious people and I love us.
P.P.S. This is a cousin to my pumpkin spice post from October, Where’s the Pumpkin?, and no, they’re not the same pumpkin. That one was about the marketing of a feeling. This one’s about the politics of an actual pie.

